Louis Vuitton's Campaign Against Free Speech - Slate Magazine (blog)

var SG_Debug = {};SG_Debug.initialTime = new Date();SG_Debug.pagedebug=(window.location.href.indexOf("pagedebug=true") > 0)?true:false;SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Top of head.jsp');Louis Vuitton's Campaign Against Free Speech.slb-currentblog-bg { background-color: #006699; }.slb-currentblog-clr{ color: #006699; }a.slb-currentblog-clr:active, a.slb-currentblog-clr:hover { color: #006699; }.slb-currentblog-logo-large { background:url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat 0px -92px; height:75px; width:568px;}.slb-currentblog-logo-small { background:url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat -90px -167px; height:30px; width:100px;}.slb-currentblog-twit-header { background:url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat 0 0; height:47px; width:336px;}.slb-currentblog-skybox { background: url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat scroll -1px -7px; display: block;}.slb-currentblog-tag { background: url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat scroll -9px -7px; display: block; height: 78px; width: 128px; border: solid 1px #ccc;}.slb-currentblog-defaultimg { background: url('/content/slate/blogs/moneybox/jcr:content/sprite.gif') no-repeat scroll 0 -167px; display: block;} SA.redirection_mobile ({ noredirection_param:"noredirection", mobile_prefix : "mobile", cookie_hours : "2",keep_path : true });var wp_meta_data = {"authors":["Matthew Yglesias"],"contentType":"blog","page_id":"221120309005","keywords":["Louis Vuitton"],"section":"Business","rubric":"Blog"}; SG_Debug && SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Bottom of head.jsp'); News & Politics Tech Business Arts Life Health & Science Sports Double X Podcasts Photos Video Slatest Blogs MySlate 99+ SG_Debug && SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Bottom of header.jsp'); Moneybox A blog about business and economics. ?OLDER HARP Worked for Me: Thanks Obama! NEWER ? What New York Could Learn From North Dakota

Louis Vuitton's Campaign Against Free Speech By Matthew Yglesias

?|?Posted Friday, March 9, 2012, at 12:34 PM ET

Tweet MYSLATESave this story. Follow all Blog articles. Follow the Moneybox blog. Follow stories by Matthew Yglesias. MySlate is a new tool that you track your favorite parts Slate. You can follow authors and sections, track comment threadsyou're interested in, and more. $(".sl-art-illo-cntr").css("padding","0px"); $(".sl-art-illo-cntr").css("margin-bottom","0px");if(($("#slate_image_id").parent()[0] != undefined) && ($("#slate_image_id").parent()[0].nodeName =="A")) { $("#slate_image_id").parent().attr("id","slate_image_href"); $("#slate_image_href").attr('target', '_self');}

Part of America's trend over the past couple of decades toward insanely overbroad readings of intellectual property concepts has been a trend toward firms trying to assert that their ownership of trademarks constitutes some kind of wide-ranging repeal of the first amendment. Thus, Luis Vuitton has decided to send a cease and desist order to the University of Pennsylvania Law School over the poster you see on the left.

Their lawyer, Michael Pantalony, writes that "this egregious action is not only a serious willful infringement and knowingly dilutes the LV Trademarks, but also may mislead others into thinking this type of unlawful activity is somehow 'legal' or constitutes 'fair use' because the Penn Intellectual Property Group is sponsoring a seminar on fashion law and 'must be experts.' "

The university's general counsel is mounting a fairly narrow defense based on the right to parody, and of course that's the smart legal strategy since the lawyer's job is to win the case and not make a point. But from a journalistic perspective, quibbling over whether or not this poster constitutes a parody is really missing the boat. In a decent society you have to have an overwhelming presumption that a person is allowed to put whatever he wants on a poster. That's what it means to leave in a country featuring the freedom of speech and freedom of the press. There are of course restrictions on where you can place a poster, but that's not what's at issue here. The claim is that Louis Vuitton has the authority to say what kinds of posters Penn Law School may and may not print and design. But why would that be? Under what circumstances would we want to grant private firms wide-ranging authority to censor the speech of academic institutions? I can't really think of any.

Now consider a different situation. Penn, like most universities, licenses and sells Penn-branded apparel. Louis Vuitton is also in the apparel business. You can imagine Penn or a Penn-licensee creating some Penn-licensed apparel that featured a pattern which might lead a consumer to believe that it was Vuitton-designed Penn-licensed apparal. Louis Vuitton might then reasonably order them to cease and desist their dilution of Vuitton's distinctive mark. Then you might have a controversy as to whether the pattern constituted some kind of parody worthy of an exemption. But when it comes to a poster there's simply no possible question of trademark law. Imagine Penn researchers want to host a discussion of research on the public health effect of soda, and want to advertise that panel with a photograph of a Coca-Cola can. If Coke tries to turn around and sue them, we don't want Penn's right to discuss Coca-Cola to be limited by some kind of parody concept. The issue is that Coke is in the beverage trade and Louis Vuitton is in the apparel trade whereas these are posters. There's no possible confusion or dilution.

? Tweet ?OLDER HARP Worked for Me: Thanks Obama! NEWER ? What New York Could Learn From North Dakota .sl-ssgal{border:1px dotted #666;border-left:none;border-right:none;display:none;margin:0 0 10px 0;padding:0 0 10px 0;width:568px;}.sl-ssgal-head{font:normal 1.384em arial, sans-serif;padding:5px 0;text-align:center;text-transform:uppercase;}.sl-ssgal-cntr{}.sl-ssgal-menu{list-style-type:none;margin:0 auto;width:471px;}.sl-ssgal-item{float:left;margin:0 15px 0 0;width:147px;}.sl-ssgal-item-last{margin:0;}.sl-ssgal-link{color:#333;font-weight:bold;font-size:0.923em;}.sl-ssgal-img{border:1px solid #666;height:88px;width:145px;}Slate Slide ShowsAsk Me Why I Hate My CandidateThe Romney-Inspired Age Guessing Game Instagram Campaign Photos Worth Looking At .sl-ssgal { margin:0; padding:0px 0 10px 0; display: block; } .sl-ssgal-head { padding: 10px 0 5px;} Click here to load comments. ? PREV NEXT ?

Like Follow RSS Matthew Yglesias ?is Slate's business and economics correspondent. Before joining the magazine he worked for ThinkProgress, the Atlantic, TPM Media, and the American Prospect. His first book, Heads in the Sand, was published by Wiley in 2008. His second, The Rent Is Too Damn High, will be published by Simon & Schuster in March 2012. View My Network on Slate? 1. Why Apple's iPad Competitors Don't Stand a Chance—and Maybe Never Will

By Farhad Manjoo | March 8, 2012 2. It’s Been 44 Days Since I’ve Touched a Dollar Bill
By Seth Stevenson | March 1, 2012 3. What Will Beggars Do When No One Carries Loose Change?
By Will Oremus | March 5, 2012 4. Why Did the KKK Lose Nearly One-Third of its Chapters in One Year?
By Brian Palmer | March 8, 2012 5. Help! My Mother-in-Law Might Be Poisoning Me.
By Emily Yoffe | March 8, 2012 1. Why Apple's iPad Competitors Don't Stand a Chance—and Maybe Never Will

By Farhad Manjoo | March 8, 2012 2. How the Supreme Court Flooded the 2012 Campaign Season With Cold, Hard Cash
By Richard L. Hasen | March 9, 2012 3. Why Did the KKK Lose Nearly One-Third of its Chapters in One Year?
By Brian Palmer | March 8, 2012 4. U.S. Jobs Trend Favors Old Over Young
By Martin Hutchinson | March 9, 2012 5. Put Down the Frosted Mug! Cold Temperatures Ruin Good Beer
By Mark Garrison | March 7, 2012 $('.slb-rrw-mps-menu-link-ms').click(function() { $(".slb-rrw-shared").css("display","block"); $(".slb-rrw-read").css("display","none"); $("#tabchange").removeClass("slb-rrw-mps-mode-read"); $("#tabchange").addClass("slb-rrw-mps-mode-shared"); }); $('.slb-rrw-mps-menu-link-mr').click(function() { $(".slb-rrw-shared").css("display","none"); $(".slb-rrw-read").css("display","block"); $("#tabchange").removeClass("slb-rrw-mps-mode-shared"); $("#tabchange").addClass("slb-rrw-mps-mode-read"); }); SG_Debug && SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Bottom of body.jsp'); How Radical Was That Law Professor Obama Hugged? Game Change: Julianne Moore Is So Good, She Can Make Even a Liberal Feel Sorry for Sarah Palin Hate Groups Are Thriving. KKK Membership Is Dwindling. Why?
Jim Crow-Era Black Athletes Were Denied a Place in Record Books. It's Time To Change That.
Kony Trviai: Why Does the Central African Republic Have Such a Boring Name? John Carter: There’s a Fun Little Movie Buried Inside This Sci-Fi Blockbuster the fray | about us | contact us | Slate on Facebook | ad choices
feedback | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Division of the Washington Post Company
All contents ? 2012 The Slate Group, LLC. All rights reserved. User Agreement and Privacy Policy SG_Debug && SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Bottom of footer.jsp'); //apply a border to the longer element$(document).ready(function() { var main = $(".sl-main-section"); var rail = $(".sl-right-rail"); if(main.height() > rail.height()) { main.css('border-right', 'solid 1px #e6e6e6') } else { rail.css('border-left', 'solid 1px #e6e6e6') } });// load manually -- async and explicit are mutually exclusivewindow.___gcfg = { parsetags: 'explicit' }; //Google Plus One Code --> (function() { var po = document.createElement('script'); po.type = 'text/javascript';// po.async = true; po.src = 'https://apis.google.com/js/plusone.js'; var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s.parentNode.insertBefore(po, s); })();SG_Debug && SG_Debug.pagedebug && window.console && console.log && console.log('[' + (new Date()-SG_Debug.initialTime)/1000 + ']' + ' Bottom of footer-scripts.jsp');
Louis Vuitton Handbags
Louis Vuitton Outlet
lv bags